Beijing Misreads China’s Policy Needs
.
Beijing’s National Development and Reform Commission (NDRC) acknowledges the economy’s imbalances. China suffers from supply capacities far in excess of domestic needs or demands, leaving the country uncomfortably dependent on exports.
In response, the Commission has promulgated policies that it claims will increase demand, especially among China’s consumers. But most of the Commission’s new policies emphasize investing in expansion and modernization, activities that, by their nature, will increase supply and seem set to exacerbate the economy’s unfortunate imbalance and dependence on exports.
What the Commission proposes to increase consumer spending can only be described as weak. It has announced that it will continue the trade-in subsidies Beijing put in place last year. The idea of these practices was that Chinese consumers would buy new products more freely by making it attractive for people to trade in their existing automobiles and household appliances.
The rest of the NDRC plan emphasizes major projects in high-technology industries and advanced manufacturing, including new energy, artificial intelligence (AI), and biotech. It also seeks subsidized interest rates on loans to businesses for expansion and modernization, with special guarantees to support such investments in small- and medium-sized businesses.
On balance, then, these new measures will likely worsen China’s supply-demand problem, intensifying the economy’s dependence on exports at a time when the United States, Europe, the West generally, and Japan are showing an increased hostility to China trade. To be sure, China and the European Union (EU) have recently worked out an accord on sales of Chinese-made electric vehicles (EVs) to European customers, and Washington has moderated its tariff threats.
Zhou Chen, head of the NDRC’s department of national economy, deserves credit for calling attention to China’s dire supply-demand imbalance. The matter needs immediate attention if China is to relieve its problematic dependence on exports and regain growth momentum. Sadly, the Commission’s policies to date are not likely to improve matters. Indeed, they seem set to exacerbate them.
Until Beijing can formulate more forceful policies to revive the Chinese consumer, it is hard to generate much optimism about the economy’s growth prospects.


