Never Forget the 1989 Tiananmen Square Massacre

CommentaryAs I watched the military parades at the start of Queen Elizabeth II’s Platinum Jubilee celebrations on June 2, I was full of admiration for the men and women in uniform who not only marched and played music with remarkable precision and discipline, but whose very purpose is to defend us as a country and our values of freedom, democracy, the rule of law, and human rights. They answer to a civilian, democratically-elected government and a monarch who, though unelected, embodies both in her role and in her character a constitutional assurance to safeguard our democracy. Tens of thousands of people joined the celebrations in London’s parks and streets, and millions more participated across the United Kingdom and around the world. I was surprised to learn through the media commentary that the Commonwealth, a network of 54 countries with the queen at its head, represents 2.6 billion people, almost a third of the world’s population. But as we mark the extraordinary 70th anniversary of the queen’s coronation, my thoughts quickly turn to another anniversary that we commemorate today, the Tiananmen Square massacre in Beijing on June 4, 1989. Thirty-three years ago today, in China, the most populous country in the world with 1.4 billion people, Beijing ordered its army to turn their guns and tanks on its own citizens. The death toll is estimated to be at least 10,000, with thousands more injured, arrested, jailed, and tortured. Tanks sit in a street in Beijing on June 6, 1989, two days after the suppression of the pro-democracy protests in Tiananmen Square. (David Turnley/Getty Images) To paraphrase the title of Charles Dickens’ novel “A Tale of Two Cities,” this weekend, the world focuses on a tale of two armies: the British Army, with the queen at its head, the epitome of public service and duty, and the People’s Liberation Army, with the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) dictators in charge, the embodiment of repression, inhumanity, cruelty, mendacity, impunity, and criminality. No one would suggest that the British army is perfect—but the difference is this: it is accountable to the people through our democratically-elected leaders, the system addresses acts of wrongdoing, and their objective is to protect the country, its people, and its values, not a political party or an ideology. In contrast, the People’s Liberation Army’s name is a misnomer. It is against the people and against “liberation.” It should be renamed “the People’s Repression Army.” That is why it is so vital that we remember the anniversary of the Tiananmen Square massacre for three reasons. First, the CCP regime is trying desperately to make us forget. Across China, generations of people have grown up since 1989 with no knowledge of the scenes of barbarity that occurred in Tiananmen Square, surrounding streets, and in cities across the country on June 4 that year. The butchers of Beijing and their successors in Zhongnanhai have censored news, spread propaganda, and brainwashed people so successfully that many people genuinely do not know, and those who do are afraid to remember. Until three years ago, Hong Kong was the only place under Chinese sovereignty that could still commemorate the June 4 massacre. Thousands of people would gather each year in Victoria Park. When I lived in Hong Kong for the first five years after the handover, I would join the crowds in a candlelit vigil. Now those vigils are banned under the draconian national security law imposed by Beijing on Hong Kong. Some activists, like lawyer Chow Hang-tung, are serving long jail sentences for organizing such vigils. Last year, no formal vigil was permitted, but Catholic churches held masses and Hongkongers flashed their mobile phone torches as a sign of remembrance. This year, the Catholic Church in Hong Kong has said it will not hold any masses, and the police closed Victoria Park, warning that even visiting a park on June 4 could be a crime. Illegal gatherings could result in five years in prison. Presumably, flashing a phone torch light is risky, too. Late last year, all remaining symbols of remembrance for the Tiananmen Square massacre—the Pillar of Shame, the Goddess of Democracy, and other memorabilia—were torn down and banned. Beijing wants to erase the memory of the June 4 massacre, even in Hong Kong. Despite this, some brave Hongkongers still found ways to mark the anniversary. Miniature figurines of the Goddess of Democracy were hidden around the campus of the Chinese University of Hong Kong in defiance of the authorities. Thousands of participants take part in a memorial vigil in Victoria Park on June 4, 2020, in Hong Kong, China, to honor the victims of the 1989 Tiananmen Square massacre. (Sung Pi-lung/The Epoch Times) That is all the more reason why we who have freedom outside China must ensure that the spotlight remains on the June 4 anniversary. Later today, I will be speaking at three different rallies in London at key landmarks: outside t

Never Forget the 1989 Tiananmen Square Massacre

Commentary

As I watched the military parades at the start of Queen Elizabeth II’s Platinum Jubilee celebrations on June 2, I was full of admiration for the men and women in uniform who not only marched and played music with remarkable precision and discipline, but whose very purpose is to defend us as a country and our values of freedom, democracy, the rule of law, and human rights.

They answer to a civilian, democratically-elected government and a monarch who, though unelected, embodies both in her role and in her character a constitutional assurance to safeguard our democracy.

Tens of thousands of people joined the celebrations in London’s parks and streets, and millions more participated across the United Kingdom and around the world. I was surprised to learn through the media commentary that the Commonwealth, a network of 54 countries with the queen at its head, represents 2.6 billion people, almost a third of the world’s population.

But as we mark the extraordinary 70th anniversary of the queen’s coronation, my thoughts quickly turn to another anniversary that we commemorate today, the Tiananmen Square massacre in Beijing on June 4, 1989.

Thirty-three years ago today, in China, the most populous country in the world with 1.4 billion people, Beijing ordered its army to turn their guns and tanks on its own citizens. The death toll is estimated to be at least 10,000, with thousands more injured, arrested, jailed, and tortured.

Epoch Times Photo
Tanks sit in a street in Beijing on June 6, 1989, two days after the suppression of the pro-democracy protests in Tiananmen Square. (David Turnley/Getty Images)

To paraphrase the title of Charles Dickens’ novel “A Tale of Two Cities,” this weekend, the world focuses on a tale of two armies: the British Army, with the queen at its head, the epitome of public service and duty, and the People’s Liberation Army, with the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) dictators in charge, the embodiment of repression, inhumanity, cruelty, mendacity, impunity, and criminality.

No one would suggest that the British army is perfect—but the difference is this: it is accountable to the people through our democratically-elected leaders, the system addresses acts of wrongdoing, and their objective is to protect the country, its people, and its values, not a political party or an ideology. In contrast, the People’s Liberation Army’s name is a misnomer. It is against the people and against “liberation.” It should be renamed “the People’s Repression Army.”

That is why it is so vital that we remember the anniversary of the Tiananmen Square massacre for three reasons.

First, the CCP regime is trying desperately to make us forget. Across China, generations of people have grown up since 1989 with no knowledge of the scenes of barbarity that occurred in Tiananmen Square, surrounding streets, and in cities across the country on June 4 that year.

The butchers of Beijing and their successors in Zhongnanhai have censored news, spread propaganda, and brainwashed people so successfully that many people genuinely do not know, and those who do are afraid to remember.

Until three years ago, Hong Kong was the only place under Chinese sovereignty that could still commemorate the June 4 massacre. Thousands of people would gather each year in Victoria Park. When I lived in Hong Kong for the first five years after the handover, I would join the crowds in a candlelit vigil. Now those vigils are banned under the draconian national security law imposed by Beijing on Hong Kong.

Some activists, like lawyer Chow Hang-tung, are serving long jail sentences for organizing such vigils. Last year, no formal vigil was permitted, but Catholic churches held masses and Hongkongers flashed their mobile phone torches as a sign of remembrance.

This year, the Catholic Church in Hong Kong has said it will not hold any masses, and the police closed Victoria Park, warning that even visiting a park on June 4 could be a crime. Illegal gatherings could result in five years in prison. Presumably, flashing a phone torch light is risky, too.

Late last year, all remaining symbols of remembrance for the Tiananmen Square massacre—the Pillar of Shame, the Goddess of Democracy, and other memorabilia—were torn down and banned. Beijing wants to erase the memory of the June 4 massacre, even in Hong Kong.

Despite this, some brave Hongkongers still found ways to mark the anniversary. Miniature figurines of the Goddess of Democracy were hidden around the campus of the Chinese University of Hong Kong in defiance of the authorities.

hong kong-june 4 protests 3
Thousands of participants take part in a memorial vigil in Victoria Park on June 4, 2020, in Hong Kong, China, to honor the victims of the 1989 Tiananmen Square massacre. (Sung Pi-lung/The Epoch Times)

That is all the more reason why we who have freedom outside China must ensure that the spotlight remains on the June 4 anniversary. Later today, I will be speaking at three different rallies in London at key landmarks: outside the prime minister’s residence in Downing Street, Piccadilly Circus, and outside the Chinese embassy. We must not be silenced.

The second reason we must keep the spotlight on the Tiananmen Square massacre is simply this: we should have learned the lesson in 1989 that a regime that turns its guns on its people is not a regime to be trusted, respected, or legitimized. It says a lot about the nature and character of a regime if it is prepared to slaughter thousands of peaceful protesters in full view of the world.

Until recently, we failed to learn that lesson. For a time, myself included, many of us thought that we saw signs of liberalization in China in the 1990s and early 2000s. I traveled more than 50 times in China throughout that period, including living in China several times for short stints and living in Hong Kong for the first five years after the handover. I made many Chinese friends, including human rights lawyers, bloggers, religious leaders, and civil society activists, who appeared at the time to have a certain amount of space and who themselves felt cautiously optimistic that it might expand further.

Few of us were so naïve as not to understand that the CCP regime was always repressive, but it did appear that for a while, the red lines had become more distant, and space for some degree of free thought had expanded. Over the past decade of Xi Jinping’s rule, that view has been entirely reversed, as literally all that space has been shut down and many of its inhabitants locked up.

In China today, there are slow-motion June 4 massacres taking place all the time. Not with tanks and guns, but with repressive laws, prison camps, surveillance technology, and instruments of torture.

The Uyghurs are facing genocide, as is increasingly recognized by the international community. Atrocities in Tibet have increased. The persecution of Christians has intensified. The persecution of Falun Gong and forced organ harvesting has continued. And Hong Kong has turned from one of Asia’s freest and most open cities into a police state.

Epoch Times Photo
British Conservative Party MPs Nusrat Ghani (C), Sir Iain Duncan Smith (R), and UK director of the World Uyghur Congress UK Director Rahima Mahmut at a demonstration call on the British Parliament to vote to recognize the alleged persecution of China’s Muslim minority Uyghur people as genocide and crimes against humanity in London on April 22, 2021. (Justin Tallis/AFP via Getty Images)

I was denied entry to Hong Kong in 2017, have received numerous threats to myself and my mother over recent years, and have been warned by the Hong Kong Police Force officially that I could face jail in Hong Kong if they could get their hands on me. That does not worry me because there is little they can do as long as I don’t get extradited, but it illustrates the dangers for Hongkongers, Uyghurs, Tibetans, and mainland Chinese-exiled dissidents. If the CCP is willing to threaten a foreign activist in this way, the dangers for those it regards as its “own people” are even greater.

And that leads me to my third reason why today’s anniversary matters. We must always learn from history. Russian President Vladimir Putin’s invasion of Ukraine has surely taught us that. A regime that is allowed to massacre thousands of people with impunity is not only a threat to its own people—it becomes a threat to us.

All dictatorships are like bad drivers with one eye in the rear-view mirror. If no one tries to pull them over for their speeding or drunken driving, they’ll carry on, causing carnage. Until now, for 33 years, the rest of the world has failed to keep the CCP regime in check—and as a result, the regime has been emboldened. That is why today we have a Uyghur genocide, the total destruction of Hong Kong’s freedoms, the continued tragedy of Tibet, religious persecution, organ harvesting, and the all-out assault on civil society in China.

For my new book, “The China Nexus: Thirty Years In and Around the Chinese Communist Party’s Tyranny,” which will be published in October, I interviewed several prominent activists and journalists who were in Beijing on June 4, 1989. And their stories are consistent.

Yang Jianli, a prominent exiled Chinese activist, told me that in the early hours of June 4, he and his colleagues cycled into the square.

“We saw the troops open fire, and we saw many people killed,” he told me in an emotional online call. “It was so hard to believe. I saw tanks moving at high speed, tear gas, machine gun fire, and I heard so much screaming. That was what propelled me into becoming an activist.”

Epoch Times Photo
Taken care of by others, an unidentified foreign journalist (2nd-r) is carried out from the clash site between the army and students near Tiananmen Square on June 4, 1989. According to Amnesty International, five years after the crushing of the Chinese pro-democracy movement, “thousands” of prisoners remained in jail. (Tommy Cheng/AFP/Getty Images)

Veteran Canadian journalist Jan Wong, author of “Red China Blues,” who was in Tiananmen Square on June 4, 1989, told me what she saw firsthand.

“They were shooting, people were running, and people tried to rescue others,” she said. “They brought out bodies on bicycle seats and pedicabs. They just ran into gunfire.”

Later that night, Wong herself narrowly missed a bullet fired into the wall of the Beijing Hotel, just inches from the balcony where she had stood observing the carnage.

Wong saw the infamous “Tank Man” scene in real-time.

“The army had been running people over, and I had watched the tanks. Then my husband pointed to this man standing in front of a tank. … I saw this whole dance between ‘Tank Man’ and the tank. He tried to stop the tank like a soccer goalie. Then he climbed onto the tank, tried to talk, then climbed down again,” she recalled. Then he “melted into the crowd.”

In addition to “Tank Man,” Wong believes that the tank driver was a “real hero” because he refused to run the man over.

Epoch Times Photo
A Chinese man stands alone blocking a line of tanks heading east on Beijing’s Changan Blvd. on June 5, 1989. (Jeff Widener/AP Photo)

I believe we need to do three things going forward.

We need to ensure that history keeps a record that—despite Beijing’s best efforts—the massacres of 1989 are not forgotten and that one day the cause for which so many gave their lives prevails in China: freedom, justice, peace, and truth.

Then we need to try to find the “tank drivers” in the regime who refused to run people over. As hard as it may be, we have to do to the CCP regime what they do with such skill to us—we must pursue a divide-and-rule policy and cause them to split.

And at the same time, we must create a “United Front” to fight their “United Front.” Unity does not mean uniformity. We can welcome and respect the diversity of thought, strategy, tactics, and approach. But we should endeavor to encourage a “unity of spirit and purpose.”

Egos and rivalries should be set to one side, personal agendas suspended, and everyone who opposes the regime in Beijing should find a way to work together—or at least not work against each other. Only when we do that—and create our own “United Front”—can we have a hope of advancing.

Thirty-three years on from the massacre, let us not allow China’s fallen heroes to be forgotten. And let us remind the free world, as a large part of it celebrates an icon of human dignity, the queen, this weekend, of the big challenge that faces us ahead in confronting the problem of the CCP regime. Action on that front would go some way toward respecting the legacy of those who stood—and fell—in Tiananmen Square in 1989.

Views expressed in this article are the opinions of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of The Epoch Times.


Follow

Benedict Rogers is a human rights activist and writer. He is the co-founder and chief executive of Hong Kong Watch, senior analyst for East Asia at the international human rights organization CSW, co-founder and deputy chair of the UK Conservative Party Human Rights Commission, and member of the advisory group of the Inter-Parliamentary Alliance on China (IPAC), the International Coalition to End Transplant Abuse in China, and the Stop Uyghur Genocide Campaign.