Canadian MPs Voice Support for Bill That Would Make Organ Trafficking Illegal
Several MPs say they are optimistic that a bill which would create new offences in relation to human organ trafficking will soon become law, after many similar bills over the past 15 years died when Parliament was dissolved.Bill S-223, introduced by Sen. Salma Ataullahjan, would make it a criminal offence for a Canadian citizen or a permanent resident to go abroad to receive an organ taken from someone who did not give informed consent to the removal of the organ. The bill would also amend the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act to deny a permanent resident or foreign national access to Canada if they have engaged in activities relating to the trafficking of human organs. The bill passed second reading in the House of Commons in May and was presented to the Foreign Affairs Committee for review, which held a private hearing on Nov. 23 to consider the legislation. The bill will have passed the committee and automatically return to the House on Nov. 28. Liberal MP Sameer Zuberi, who was the second sponsor of the bill, told The Epoch Times that it “sends a signal that illegal organ harvesting cannot be accepted by us as a country and that we will address this concretely.” ‘15 Years in the Making’ Conservative MP Garnett Genuis, who serves as his party’s shadow minister for international development, said he is confident that the bill will be passed, adding that it has come a long way since Parliament first sought legislative measures to combat forced organ harvesting and trafficking in 2008. “This bill has been 15 years in the making. It was Canadians who really identified the problem of forced organ harvesting and trafficking and exposed it to the world, and yet our country is taking so long to finally legislate on this issue,” Genuis told The Epoch Times on Nov. 23. “I’m very optimistic, though, that with this automatic reporting coming to the House, this bill will become law in Canada before the end of the year. And we’re going to work towards making that the result.” The first piece of legislation aimed at fighting human organ trafficking was proposed by former Liberal MP Borys Wrzesnewskyj back in 2008. His Bill C-500 was introduced in February of that year but died when Parliament was dissolved. In 2009, he made a second attempt with Bill C-381, which also died when Parliament was dissolved. In 2013, then-Liberal MP Irwin Cotler introduced similar legislation, Bill C-561, which also failed to become law. After Cotler retired, Genuis re-introduced C-561 in the 42nd Parliament. In December 2019, Ataullahjan also put forth a similar bill, S-204, but after Prime Minister Justin Trudeau prorogued Parliament in 2020, all legislative business ceased and the bill had only passed its first reading at the Senate. Organ Harvesting After The Epoch Times broke the news in 2006 that the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) was involved in forced organ harvesting for profit from adherents of the spiritual practice Falun Gong in China, human rights activists approached former MP David Kilgour and asked him to investigate the alleged crime. Kilgour joined forces with human rights lawyer David Matas, and their investigation culminated in a report, later followed by a book titled “Bloody Harvest,” concluding that the allegations were true. Their findings inspired other investigations into the trade of forced organ harvesting and trafficking, in China and around the world, with countries making efforts to halt practices like “organ tourism.” Benedict Rogers, a renowned British human rights activist and journalist, said the work of the 2019 China Tribunal—an independent tribunal that investigated the allegations of forced organ harvesting from Falun Gong prisoners of conscience in China—chaired by Sir Geoffrey Nice, was pivotal in further exposing the CCP’s organ harvesting crimes. “I think that tribunal is an incredibly important tribunal because … it’s an independent body, chaired by a very distinguished lawyer, saying that this barbaric practice is happening in China on a widespread level, and it is a crime against humanity,” Rogers told The Epoch Times on Nov. 23. Donna Ho and Isaac Teo contributed to this report Follow Andrew Chen is an Epoch Times reporter based in Toronto.
Udumbara
Several MPs say they are optimistic that a bill which would create new offences in relation to human organ trafficking will soon become law, after many similar bills over the past 15 years died when Parliament was dissolved.
Bill S-223, introduced by Sen. Salma Ataullahjan, would make it a criminal offence for a Canadian citizen or a permanent resident to go abroad to receive an organ taken from someone who did not give informed consent to the removal of the organ.
The bill would also amend the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act to deny a permanent resident or foreign national access to Canada if they have engaged in activities relating to the trafficking of human organs.
The bill passed second reading in the House of Commons in May and was presented to the Foreign Affairs Committee for review, which held a private hearing on Nov. 23 to consider the legislation. The bill will have passed the committee and automatically return to the House on Nov. 28.
Liberal MP Sameer Zuberi, who was the second sponsor of the bill, told The Epoch Times that it “sends a signal that illegal organ harvesting cannot be accepted by us as a country and that we will address this concretely.”
‘15 Years in the Making’
Conservative MP Garnett Genuis, who serves as his party’s shadow minister for international development, said he is confident that the bill will be passed, adding that it has come a long way since Parliament first sought legislative measures to combat forced organ harvesting and trafficking in 2008.
“This bill has been 15 years in the making. It was Canadians who really identified the problem of forced organ harvesting and trafficking and exposed it to the world, and yet our country is taking so long to finally legislate on this issue,” Genuis told The Epoch Times on Nov. 23.
“I’m very optimistic, though, that with this automatic reporting coming to the House, this bill will become law in Canada before the end of the year. And we’re going to work towards making that the result.”
The first piece of legislation aimed at fighting human organ trafficking was proposed by former Liberal MP Borys Wrzesnewskyj back in 2008. His Bill C-500 was introduced in February of that year but died when Parliament was dissolved. In 2009, he made a second attempt with Bill C-381, which also died when Parliament was dissolved.
In 2013, then-Liberal MP Irwin Cotler introduced similar legislation, Bill C-561, which also failed to become law. After Cotler retired, Genuis re-introduced C-561 in the 42nd Parliament.
In December 2019, Ataullahjan also put forth a similar bill, S-204, but after Prime Minister Justin Trudeau prorogued Parliament in 2020, all legislative business ceased and the bill had only passed its first reading at the Senate.
Organ Harvesting
After The Epoch Times broke the news in 2006 that the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) was involved in forced organ harvesting for profit from adherents of the spiritual practice Falun Gong in China, human rights activists approached former MP David Kilgour and asked him to investigate the alleged crime.
Kilgour joined forces with human rights lawyer David Matas, and their investigation culminated in a report, later followed by a book titled “Bloody Harvest,” concluding that the allegations were true.
Their findings inspired other investigations into the trade of forced organ harvesting and trafficking, in China and around the world, with countries making efforts to halt practices like “organ tourism.”
Benedict Rogers, a renowned British human rights activist and journalist, said the work of the 2019 China Tribunal—an independent tribunal that investigated the allegations of forced organ harvesting from Falun Gong prisoners of conscience in China—chaired by Sir Geoffrey Nice, was pivotal in further exposing the CCP’s organ harvesting crimes.
“I think that tribunal is an incredibly important tribunal because … it’s an independent body, chaired by a very distinguished lawyer, saying that this barbaric practice is happening in China on a widespread level, and it is a crime against humanity,” Rogers told The Epoch Times on Nov. 23.
Donna Ho and Isaac Teo contributed to this report
